Reading Time: 3 minutes

Should the Giants trade up for J.J McCarthy? | The Herd



The New York Giants are coming off a disappointing season in which they finished with a 6-10 record and missed the playoffs for the fourth straight year. As they look to improve and get back on track next season, one option they are considering is trading up in the 2021 NFL Draft to select highly touted quarterback prospect J.J McCarthy.

McCarthy, a 5-star recruit out of IMG Academy, is widely regarded as one of the top quarterback prospects in the country. Standing at 6’2″ and weighing 195 pounds, he has all the physical tools to succeed at the next level. With a strong arm, quick release, and impressive accuracy, McCarthy has the potential to be a franchise quarterback for the Giants for years to come.

The Giants currently hold the 11th overall pick in the draft, and it is unlikely that McCarthy will still be available by the time they are on the clock. This has led to speculation that the Giants may be willing to trade up to secure the services of the talented quarterback.

There are several reasons why the Giants should consider trading up for McCarthy. Firstly, the quarterback position has been a point of concern for the team in recent years. Daniel Jones, the Giants’ current starting quarterback, has shown flashes of potential but has also struggled with turnovers and consistency. Bringing in a player of McCarthy’s caliber would provide the Giants with a long-term solution at the quarterback position.

Additionally, McCarthy’s skillset would be a perfect fit for the Giants’ offensive system. Head coach Joe Judge and offensive coordinator Jason Garrett prefer a balanced offensive attack that relies on a strong running game and efficient passing game. McCarthy’s accuracy and decision-making would allow him to thrive in this system, and he would have the weapons around him to succeed, including star running back Saquon Barkley and talented wide receiver Kenny Golladay.

Furthermore, trading up for McCarthy would send a message to the rest of the league that the Giants are serious about winning and are committed to building a championship-caliber team. It would also energize the fan base and generate excitement for the upcoming season.

However, there are also risks involved in trading up for McCarthy. The Giants would likely have to give up a significant amount of draft capital to move up in the draft, potentially sacrificing valuable future picks. This could limit their ability to address other positions of need and build depth on the roster.

Additionally, there is no guarantee that McCarthy will live up to expectations at the NFL level. While he has all the physical tools to succeed, there have been highly touted quarterback prospects in the past who have failed to translate their college success to the professional ranks. The Giants would be taking a gamble by trading up for McCarthy, and there is always the possibility that it could backfire.

In conclusion, the decision of whether or not the Giants should trade up for J.J McCarthy is a complex one. While bringing in a talented quarterback like McCarthy could provide a significant boost to the team and help them compete for a playoff spot, there are also risks involved in giving up valuable draft capital for a player who may not pan out.

Ultimately, it will be up to Giants’ management to weigh the pros and cons and make the best decision for the future of the team. If they believe that McCarthy is the quarterback of the future and can lead them to success, then trading up may be the right move. However, if they have doubts about McCarthy’s ability to succeed at the next level, they may be better off staying put and addressing other positions of need in the draft.

Only time will tell what the Giants ultimately decide to do, but one thing is for certain – the 2021 NFL Draft promises to be an exciting and pivotal moment for the franchise.



Source link

#Giants #trade #J.J #McCarthy #Herd